
Friendships begin and end for as many reasons as there are people on this planet. We move, we change, we grow beyond the confines of what kept us talking to the person to begin with. Some friendships are deeply fulfilling and make us feel less alone in the world. It is when that sort of friend goes away that it is more like a death to be mourned than just another passing thought. When someone who has walked beside one for decades chooses to stop, the loss is profound.
It was not the kind of friendship that happens when two people discover they have something in common because this friend of mine and I actually did not share much. She liked jazz; I was listening to The Rolling Stones. She was more of an indoor girl whereas I have found great joy in nature. Her family moved into one of the nicer Detroit suburbs while my family has farmed family land in rural western Michigan for generations. Our paths would eventually cross as I was self-destructing in my single dorm room at Michigan State University, and she was the one down the hall who would slide notes under my door to let me know that someone cared. I was never quite certain if she really wanted to know me or if she was just doing her duty as a good Christian.
There are times in life when the God you have been looking for shows up, even for a moment. After a particularly dark night of considering what was happening in the life of my family, I would find out that though the doctors had no explanation of why, my dad was going to live. I decided this was the miracle for which I had prayed. I would accept that God loved me and knock on the door of the note-writer down the hall. She would run out and buy me a Bible so I could accompany her to her Bible study and begin again a whole new life.
I stopped drinking for one whole week.
After that I learned that God can forgive even those of us who struggle with just about everything.
The friendship would last the rest of the spring term and I would then have to say good-bye to my friend who would get married and move to Denver, Colorado. This probably would have ended most friendships, but when I struggled to figure out what I was going to do a year later when I was about to graduate, and there were further crises I would face, my friend invited me out for a two-week vacation of sorts that ended up lasting two years. I would travel with her band as a roadie, eventually settling into a series of dead-end jobs so that I could move off her couch into an apartment.
Being a student was way more fun than being a secretary or a waitress so I found a school that would give me a graduate assistantship and moved back east. There would be another profound crisis that my friend would help me work through in addition to her own. We would stay in touch through letter-writing and since we both enjoyed this form of communication, it worked out well. I chose to go back out west to do my internship at a magazine during the summer and was again able to spend time with my friend.

After graduation I accepted a position on the east coast that did not mutually work out and would find myself testing out life briefly on the west coast before going back to Denver. (This brief California interlude was an attempt to maintain a friendship with a guy I had dated in graduate school, making me realize once and for all that it is really not possible to be friends with a guy after breaking up with him. It was also not sustainable for me to live in a house with a group of people involved in comic book production who supposedly had something to do with Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles and one night ordered a pizza with garlic and anchovies that was completely inedible. Hunger motivated me to try harder to find a better job.) It would be a relatively short time before I would meet the man I would marry and move from my studio apartment with the Murphy wall bed into his house. My friend’s marriage was ending as mine was beginning and she already had a child by that time. We had less in common than we ever had. She shouted at me one day over the phone and said she was done with me. For three years I hoped she would change her mind. Right before we left Colorado to move back east I contacted her so we could leave each other in peace. She agreed to meet me at a park. I had my own child by that time and was beginning to understand motherhood and marriage in a different context. We decided to continue to stay in touch through letters.
Letter writing transformed into emails as technology advanced. We continued to keep each other updated about our lives. She remarried and had another child. I would lose one and have two more. We would write as we were able.

It would take me seven years before I could go back to visit my friend and take a memory tour of the place I once lived. It was a wonderful trip that made me realize that I would most likely never live there again. My home was North Carolina.
After that time life took over and as it is with friendships, they come after spouses and children. I never meant to leave friendships behind and was always grateful for those who would continue to remain in touch even though it seemed like I was always at a soccer game or making dinner. Life with my family was the main course; friends were an appetizer or a snack once in awhile. I knew I could not expect much when I had so little time to offer.
I got to see my friend again when her mother died and she asked me to accompany her to the memorial service in Georgia. She said that I grieved well and was the only friend she could imagine inviting for such an occasion. We had a wonderful girlfriend weekend in Asheville afterward. She had come to visit a couple of other times; once she accompanied her son who was doing college visits. Though we did not see each other often or even email as much as we used to, I just figured she would always be a part of my life, like a sister.
After years of enjoying my part-time day job as a preschool teacher, major drama ensued and I had stories to share with my friend. She seemed entertained and I did not think much else about it. When I chose to leave the job, she offered encouragement. I felt like she was there for me, like she had always been. But little by little, she stopped sharing what she was going through and I knew less and less about her life: her marriage, her children, her career, her church.
When I began another more stressful job, it made for great storytelling and I would share the craziness of daily life in a dysfunctional office. She seemed less interested so I would try not to overwhelm with details. There was another friend who was beginning to share her work drama, so many of my stories were only heard by her. It is better to find someone who can relate to the stories without becoming burdened by them or trying to solve them like an equation. Some interactions just make good stories. It isn’t about “being negative” or judging people; it is about seeing them as characters in stories. As I’m writing this I’m realizing that maybe this coping mechanism is unique to me. I am unsure.
What has always confused me is the question: How are you? It is the most basic phrase used within social interaction and easy to answer, one may think. But for me, not so much.
A woman I worked with a long time ago explained it to me like this: The only acceptable answer to the question, “How are you?” is “Great!” It is the only answer anyone wants to hear. But what if that is a lie?, I would protest. Doesn’t matter, she would say. You are always supposed to give the acceptable answer.
I learned how to answer the question correctly, when I had to, but would save the real answer for my friend. I thought that was a part of friendship: telling the truth. I didn’t see it as “being negative,” which, by the way, also confuses me, which is why I put it in quotes. I do not understand what it means.
As I came to the conclusion that my job was heading me nowhere fast, except into greater drama, trauma, and bad health, I made the decision to leave. Much to my amazement, another job was waiting for me and I was hired on the spot. I then had to construct an exit strategy which took a lot of prayer and advice-seeking from many, including my friend. I then wrote a letter to the staff and left.
This maneuver, however, did not sit well with my friend. She suddenly was not writing words of encouragement, but was scolding me for making what she decided were bad decisions. She was making statements about my character she could not really speak to because she no longer knew me in the context of my life as it is today. Also lost on her was the fact that I now work in a right-to-work state in which an employee can be terminated the same day she gives notice, without legal obligation by the employer to pay for the two weeks. It is not uncommon to leave without notice, though naturally one likes to look good. I could not afford to do anything but protect my own interests and those of my family, leaving in what was considered a career-ending move–if that job had in any way been a career. I liked the actual work; the rest of it was unacceptable.
We had changed, my friend and I. We had lived our lives apart for decades. We had different points of view we had not had to confront. We no longer knew how the other one thought, and that became painfully clear as we exchanged emails and tried to understand one another. She was only trying to help, she said, as she took my issues to a place where she believed they began, before she even knew me. I regretted confiding in the person I thought was rooting for me from the sidelines of my life. To look over and not find her cheering made me feel alone and unloved. I felt shame.
She then said she was only interested in having an “historical friendship” with me. I had no idea what that was. Did she want to only remember me as a journalism student? What about a newlywed? A new mom? Which part of my history was acceptable for her to relate with? And how does this work since I am still here–breathing?
Devastated, I went to counseling. For six months my friend remained silent. I knew our friendship had ended. But then my husband was diagnosed with ALS, a disease with no cause, no treatment, and no cure. In a moment of weakness, and possibly because it was Christmas, I sent my “former” friend my Christmas letter, as she has been on my list for the past 30 plus years. I did not expect to hear from her.
I then receive an email in which she is still addressing me by the nickname she gave me in college: Melba. She is speaking to me like we just had coffee yesterday and is expressing what seems to be an awful lot of positive emotion for someone who did not want to hear from me again. After careful reading and rereading and reading a few more times, I notice that I am nowhere in the email. It is as if I have gone invisible or maybe “historical,” again, and am not mentioned in the least. Was she grieving over our friendship ending in the same way that she was now grieving over the inevitable demise of my husband? No. She was not. She did, however, decide that I needed to be reminded that God is still on the throne, as if all of my faith had blown away in the breeze when I received life-altering news. She recommended a book on heaven that promised to give comfort. It is not the afterlife I am worried about. It is the life I am living today, as an historical person.

I let it go. It was, after all, Christmas. I could move on in Christmas cheer. I knew I could. Six months of mourning and who knows how much money spent on the counselor. I could do this thing.
But then, since she had already “unfriended” us, she must have googled our Facebook accounts, my husband’s and mine, because there she was contributing to the birthday fundraiser on his page that was asking for money for research of the disease he is going to die from, and she was reading my blog that told the story of our lives up to the point that we arrived at his diagnosis. She even went as far as commenting on my blog. What is really great about this blog, though, is whenever someone comments, I am sent an email in which I have the option to accept or delete the comment. Until I decide, the comment is “pending” which was where our friendship was.
I would not have answered her comment but she mentioned the email in it making me think she was hoping I would respond. Maybe she had a change of heart, I foolishly thought. Maybe our friendship could be reconciled. I have no idea how I could come up with any hope at this point, yet there it was. Maybe I was not the negative person she had me pegged for. Maybe historical people have greater insight. Maybe I had grown in faith way beyond what she thought I was ever capable of doing. Maybe she really does not know me at all.
In what I thought was probably my very last chance, I poured out my heart in the most vulnerable way possible, expressing that my bottom line was that I needed an explanation. I needed to know why above everything else. Why was she choosing not to tell me why we could no longer be friends? Or was she? What was it that finally caused her to walk away, like she said she had to do, and not only that but walk away without feeling anything? She had come to think of me with indifference, she said, even though her email was the angriest email I may have ever received.
All she would say was that she would have been a monster to not comment on the tragic news about my husband.
If you are reading this and suddenly remember that an ex-friend, ex-husband, ex-lover, or ex-anyone else is experiencing tremendous loss, do that ex-person an enormous favor and do NOT send your condolences. Trust me, it does not help.
I responded by saying that she was already a monster of the very worst kind–the kind who thought she could come out of hiding to shed a sympathetic tear after earlier walking away from a friend with indifference instead of giving an explanation or offering any hope of reconciliation. I ended by saying that if she did not want to hear from me again that she should stop contacting me. That I was praying for her, which was what she always said to me. And that I hoped God would heal her and when he did, I would be there. I knew this would just make her angry, but I said it anyway. I could not say there would never be any hope. I cannot say that to anyone. I always leave the door open. Even when that allows it to get slammed in my face.
Looking online for the explanation I needed, I came across a well-written article in The Atlantic by Julie Beck who wrote: “If you never see your friends in person, you’re not really sharing experiences so much as just keeping each other updated on your separate lives. It becomes a relationship based on storytelling rather than shared living—not bad, just not the same.”
Eureka!, I thought, in my typical nerdy way. This was the answer! This is how we had been conducting our friendship for many, many years, and it was not enough. For her.
This was when I realized that storytelling is enough for me. I live to write the story, to read the story, to live the story. I spent a great deal of my childhood alone, making friends with the characters in the books I read. As I grew, the characters in the movies I watched have and do keep me company. I know I am unusual in this regard. But it suddenly made so much sense as to why having a long-distance friendship would no longer be of any use to someone.
Or maybe it is just this one friend who does not want to go on, considering that we cannot see each other often enough. There are friends from where I grew up that I am still able to visit and feel a lot of love for. Friends who weathered those fierce Michigan winters with me with lake effect snowfall and unbelievably cold temperatures from Halloween to Easter. Friends who lived in or near a town of 2,000 people who understood that one had to drive 40 miles to go out to a movie or out to dinner. Friends who knew everyone in the area and were related to many of them. Friends who know me and love me even after I moved away and have now lived in the state of North Carolina longer than I ever lived in my home state of Michigan. This shared history is what keeps our friendships alive; these friendships are truly historical!
My friend is not like me. She prefers to be with friends she can see often. I am unaware of her historical friendships, but she probably has a few. Like it was impossible being friends with the guy I once dated, it is impossible to change the status of a friendship from close to something indefinable or unrecognizable. “I can love you without having you in my life and that is what I have chosen,” is how she ended her last email before telling me she was praying for me and wishing me well. It does not feel much like love, but it is ok and maybe even healthy at this point since it is closer to the truth. And we can tell the truth. We are no longer caught in the sentiment of Christmas. It is a whole new year, a new decade even.
















